Studies for the Disputa (recto); Studies for the Disputa (verso)

Raphael1509 - 1511

The J. Paul Getty Museum

The J. Paul Getty Museum

In this preliminary study for his Disputafresco in the Vatican, Raphael Sanzio rendered several of the figures with extraordinary clarity and economy. The central philosopher turning intently away from the viewer, the ghostly hooded figure on the right, and the men in animated discussion behind all appear in detail. Raphael varied the lines from the squiggles of the philosopher's hair to the straight folds of the standing monk's cloak, which seem to barely touch the page. This sheet also reveals the artist's thought process as he worked up the main figure from the nude, carefully manipulating the anatomical details so as to provide a believable structure and volume for the completely draped figure in the fresco.

The verso contains three even quicker sketches of the philosopher, along with an earlier idea for the young man who turns outward in the fresco's left foreground.

Show lessRead more
  • Title: Studies for the Disputa (recto); Studies for the Disputa (verso)
  • Creator: Raphael (Raffaello Sanzio)
  • Date: 1509 - 1511
  • Location Created: Italy
  • Physical Dimensions: 31.1 x 20.8 cm (12 1/4 x 8 3/16 in.)
  • External Link: Find out more about this object on the Museum website.
  • Medium: Pen and brown ink (recto); Pen and brown ink (verso)
  • Source Credit Line: The J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles
  • Object Type: Drawing
  • Object Status: Permanent Collection
  • Number: 84.GA.920
  • Markings: Markings: (Recto) at bottom left corner, collection mark of Sir Joshua Reynolds (L.2364); at bottom right corner, collection mark of Jonathan Richardson, Jr. (L.2170).
  • Display Location: Not currently on view
  • Department: Drawings
  • Culture: Italian
  • Classification: Drawings