patents, in its support for the free software
movement, and in its resistance to Big Con-
tent's attempts to shape global information
policy, is transforming itself into an open
source nation - a proving ground for the
proposition that the future of ideas doesn't
have to be the program of tightly controlled
digital rights now headed our way via Red-
mond, Hollywood, and Washington, DC.
No surprise there either, actually. In a
world divided into the content-rich and the
content-poor, it's increasingly clear to those
on the losing side of the divide that the tra-
ditional means of addressing the imbalance
piracy - is a stopgap solution at best.
Sooner or later some country was bound
to square off with the IP empire and be the
first to insist, as a matter of state policy and
national identity, on an alternative.
The only question is, why Brazil?
Sooner or later some country would
square off with the global IP empire.
And Brazil was fertile ground for it.
In 1996, in response to Brazil's alarming
rate of AIDS infection, the government of
then-president Fernando Henrique Cardoso
guaranteed distribution of the new retroviral
drug cocktails to all HIV carriers in the
country. Five years later, with the AIDS rate
dropping, it was clear that the plan was wise
but - at the prices being charged for the
patented drugs in the cocktail, utterly un-
sustainable. Brazil's
economy is the world's
10th largest, but it is also the world's most
unequal, with 10 percent of the population
in control of almost half the wealth and more
than 20 percent living in desperate poverty.
Those are the sorts of figures that strain a
government's budget even when it's not
trying to stop the spread of AIDS.
AIDS program, the problem took on a partic- (:08 Thievery Corporation/ DC 3000
ular urgency.
His first approach was to go to the key
patent holders, the US pharmaceutical giant
Merck and the Swiss firm Roche, and ask for
a volume discount. When the companies said
no, Serra raised the stakes. Under
Brazilian
law, he informed them, he had the power in
cases of national emergency to license local
labs to produce patented drugs, royalty free,
and he would use it if necessary. Merck
immediately caved, but Roche stood its
ground until August 2001, when Serra pre-
pared to make good on his threat by drawing
up the required paperwork. It was the first
time a poor country had even come close
to breaking a drug patent- and Roche,
stunned, returned to the bargaining table
with a newly cooperative attitude. In return
Such was the arithmetic that led José Serra
-economist, politician, and the man who set
Brazil on its path toward IP independence -
to take an interest in the topic. "I always
found intellectual property boring," says
Serra, appointed health minister under Car-
doso in 1998. "Among economists, intellec-
tual property isn't considered one of the
noble questions." But with the drug patents
for Serra's agreement to play nice, the drug-
maker would reduce the price of its drug in
Brazil to less than half what it was (and less
than Brazil's cost to go it alone).
This was a powerful lesson in the politics
of intellectual property- and Brazil was
fertile ground for it. As it happens, the open
source community in Brazil has long been
one of the most active, with a half-dozen
GNU/Linux versions and the world's first
open source bank ATM network. That com-
munity is also undoubtedly among the most
politically mobilized.
"Every license for Office plus Windows in
Brazil - a country in which 22 million people
are starving - means we have to export 60
sacks of soybeans," says Marcelo D'Elia
Branco, coordinator of the country's Free
Software Project and liaison between the
open source community and the national
government, now headed by president Luiz
Inácio Lula da Silva. "For the right to use one
copy of Office plus Windows for one year
or a year and a half, until the next upgrade,
we have to till the earth, plant, harvest, and
export to the international markets that
"Good artists borrow; great artists steal."
So said Pablo Picasso, stealing the aphorism
from Igor Stravinsky, who most likely stole it
from T. S. Eliot. Half a century or so later,
, DC's Rob Garza and Eric Hilton
Washington ,
have built the concept into the name of their
celebrated two-man DJ unit. "We don't do
our music in a vacuum," says Hilton, alluding
to the hijacked international sounds that
form their formica-smooth electronic
grooves. Spacey Jamaican dub and cool
Brazilian bossa nova aret
re the dominant ingre-
dients, laced with Indian sitar drone, Arabic
howls, and local colors from down the block.
So they're not about to get all RIAA about
their own jams. Says Hilton: "That would be
like living in a glass house." - J.D.
Le Tigre/ Fake French
A decade back, Kathleen Hanna never
dreamed she'd be thrilling millions of club
kids. She was fronting Bikini Kill - a punk
band characterized by guitar distortion and
more about
screeching vocals - and cared
subverting the status quo than
getting a
groove on. But when the group disbanded
in 1998, Hanna came up with Le Tigre: Bikini
Kill's feminist message set to a beat. Unlike
low-fi riot grrrl acts, Hanna's New York-based
crew uses laptops, drum machines, and
synths to create music that heats up and
enlightens the dance floor. "We've always
been somewhat of a concept band," she
says. "Now we're focused on sounding good
while delivering a powerful message." - A.D.
WIRED.11|2004.193