The Arts
JAZZ
Herbie Hancock and
Bobby Hutcherson
Barbican
Jack Massarik
Each number sounded like a riff waiting for a melody to appear: Herbie Hancock relaxes into the groove for a new TV-influenced audience
Hancock's heavy hour
THE reunion of pianist Hancock
and vibraphonist Hut
XH the classic
two
modern.jazz stars of
Blue Note era, should have been a
joyful occasion. Yet for all the skill
and energy they and their
colleagues displayed, the evening
became so disappointing that one
began to wonder why
Poor programming was one
factor. Hancock, though relaxed at
the mike, made samey selections,
offering little variety of tempo or
mood. Certainly nobody was
whistling any of his music on the
way home. Each number sounded
like a riff waiting for a melody to
appear, with H and H noodling
around interminable one chord
vamps and riding increasingly
heavy rhythmic patterns.
Terri Lyne Carrington is a
terrific drummer but was
anchored by the jazz-rock beats
she and bassist Scott Colley had to
pound out. Those beats are
metronomie by nature, and that's
a fact of musical life. Without a
touch of that airy, open-ended
four-four-time, a soloist can't
really leave the ground,
The opening number, a two-key
version of Cole Porter's standard,
I Love You, was wrecked by a
CLASSICAL
The English Concert/Pinnock
Queen Elizabeth Hall
Stephen Pettitt
Period pieces never fail to impress
in D major, and both thus provided
opportunity for much trumpet and drum
resplendence. Pinnock directed richly
coloured, vigorous, well-honed
performances.
In between the
focustrument. It was an
harpsichord as solo
equal partner in the weighty B minor Flute
Sonata, BWV1000, where Lisa Beznosiuk, an
English Concert stalwart, was the elegant
flute soloist. And naturally it ruled the roo
in exuberant readings of the Concerto for
two harpsichords in C, BWV 1061, where
Pinnock was honoured by the collaboration
of his distinguished Dutch colleague Ton
Koopman, and in the Concerto for four
harpsichords in A minor (BWV 1065 - an
arrangement of a Vivaldi string concerto),
completed a convivial quartet. Thank you,
Trevor, for the English Concert. May you
flourish.
THIRTY years ago a young harpsichordist
called Trevor Pinnock k gathered around him
a small group of pioneer-musicians who had
studied the right treatises and had found,
modified, or had made for them the right
sort of instruments, thus creating one of the
two first period-style
baroque orchestras in
the land. His rivals, Christopher Hogwood's
The Academy of Ancient Music, pursued a
style that was slightly remote, one o
sound man who turned TLC's
drums to low-flying aircraft
volume, but he wasn't to blame for
the subsequent chatter of busy
beats that drowned glimpses of
Footprints and Dolphin Dance.
Hancock's solos sounded
increasingly mechanical. Only
once, during Hutcherson's spacey
original, November, did the stars
relax and stretch out as we knew
they could. If less determined to
impress, they might have grooved
that much more.
Poor pacing didn't help. As is
becoming the fashion, the
performance started late (a
(at
8.40pm) and ran uninterrupted for
two hours. During that time the
quartet played only four numbers,
an average of 30 minutes each,
and our admiration began to pale
background. But from the start Pinnock's
performances with the English Concert
Evening Standard Wednesday, 2 July 2003 45
offered unguarded brilliance and a
sometimes manic energy At the time, a few
purists' eyebrows were raised. Period-style
performance wasn't meant to be enjoyed,
was it?
Well, yes, Pinnock emphatically told us, it
was. And the English Concert's reputation
spread. But last year he decided that 30 years
in charge is enough. This was his last
concert with the band before he cedes
musical responsibility to the hugely gifted
violinist Andrew Manze, who turned up
hotfoot from Australia to lead some pieces.
specially
congratulatory, with a rather silly, s
concocted baroque medley by way of an
encore, but there was also sadness and
nostalgia in the air
It was, apart from the encore, an entirely
serious programme, consisting of music by
JS Bach. The third and fourth Orchestral
Suites acted as supporting pillars. Both are
into a cooler, more detached sort
of interest, as though watching a
TV show.
Speaking of which, this concert
was sold out, and to judge by the
queue for returns, it could have
sold out twice over. That's the
power of TV On Sunday night,
Herbie Hancock was profiled on
Channel 3's South Bank Show.
Melvyn Brage, whose arts empire
had managed to ignore the world
of jazz almost completely for
about 40 years, could thus take a
solitary bow. But with
mainstream television starved of
jazz for decades, and most
t jazz
pioneers no longer available for
interview, his gesture comes a bit
late. Sonny Rollins and Artie
Shaw are still around, Melvyn,
but you'll have to be quick.
Brazil brings
us two more
world beaters
WORLD
Gilberto Gil and Maria Bethania
Royal Festival Hall
Mark Espiner
GILBERTO Gil is no stranger to London,
He spent his political exile here in the
Sixties, and hung out in Portobello with
Pink Floyd, having upset the Brazilian
government with his edgy samba rock
which was the centre of the Tropicalia
movement. He's returned almost every
year - last year celebrating his national
team becoming champions of the world
for the fifth time with a cracking set of
Bob Marley songs. Last night, the
Brazilian ex-pat crazies were at the RFH
in force, but not just for Gil. There was
a special musical marriage going down.
At his side, sharing the bill duetting
with his
and sometimes stirring the
crowd into a frenzy on her own was
the boundlessly charismatic Maria
Bethania. The sister of
of another Brazil
Bethania also played a crucial part in
the Tropicalia movement. But its
musical subversion was less in evidence
than the spirit of jubilation.
: After the crowd booed the MC who
told them no dancing in the aisles - the
10-strong band took the stage. A heavy
battery of percussion players mixed
with the strong and subtle textures of
guitars, sax, flute, mandolin and cello.
They struck up and Maria and Gil
skipped on stage, decked head to toe in
stylish suits of dazzling white -- a funky
short dreads and Maria swept back her
black, flowing hair as they launched
into a crowd-pleasing Fe Cega, Faca
Amolada, followed swiftly by Gil's
gentle anthem Filhos De Gandhia
song dedicated to Salvador's carnival
troupe of the same name.
Maria left him to follow on with more
big hits including Marley's Is This Love
-- all of which he'd arranged with a
rather glittering edge. Then she strode
back on to take over. With the power of
Piaf and wearing the influence and
yearning passion of another great
Brazilian chanteuse Elis Regina,
Bethana belted it out. Her voice warm
as melting che next. Together and
chocolate one minute, a
separately they played a crowd-pleasing
set of 27 songs with the energy and
verve that only their football team could
match. Champions.
For great ticket deals, visit:
www.thisislondon.co.uk/tickets
W
WATERSTONE'S PICCADILLY WELCOMES
HILLARY
RODHAM CLINTON
WHO WILL BE SIGNING COPIES OF HER BEST SELLING MEMOIRS
LIVING HISTORY
FRIDAY 3RD JULY FROM 6-7PM
WATERSTONE'S. 203-206 PICCADILLY LONDON W1 TEL: 020 7851 2400