On December 3, 1888, the Council accepted the example of his work Blashfield had submitted to confirm his election as an Academician "subject to his right of replacing it with a more important one." Almost a year later, he exercised that right, making the "Saint Michael," his diploma contribution. Leonard Amico places "Saint Michael" with Blashfield's Bonnat-inspired paintings, calling it "among the finest and at the same time the most restrained of these works."