If culture is
really going to exist, it is not enough to be
the author of
social practices; these social practices
need to have
meaning for those who effectuate them.
Michel de Certeau
Mining industry (1972) by Roberto SabeyMuseu da Imagem e do Som
“Is it up to the artist to anticipate the future?” “Have you ever tried to grasp the multitude of information that is being lost due to the lack of an archive?” “How to explain the Museu da Imagem e do Som?” The future heralded by the film Nasce o MIS [The MIS is born], directed by Eduardo Leone, has come for all who, in 1970, embraced the mission of making documentary records of the unavoidable transformation processes going on in Brazilian culture and society. It is important to remember that today is also the future of all those who the Museum wanted to address: the housewife, the artist, the children, the secretary, the mechanic, and others who are repeatedly present throughout the short film. We are about to enter the second decade of the 21st century. This force full of desire for recording and sharing perceptions and experiences that moved many of the cultural projects implemented by the Museum provided the displacement of its protagonists, resulting in works that brought people, places, and things closer together.
Gradually, MIS’s Photography Collection intentionally and authorially built its collections with the generous participation of those who allowed themselves to be captured and the bold work of photographers who were interested in registering and making public what which had moved them—a word that indicates the power that some situations have in engaging the feeling of empathy that brings us closer to that which renovates our worldviews. In this context of ideas, the exhibition Moving Beings presents itself as the result of an exercise of poetic investigation in the Museum’s collection, seeking photographs on situations of displacement and itinerant work across different professional occupations. The word moventes [moving beings] encompasses varied meanings surrounding the quality of that which moves, of being “a moving entity” and, in linked gestures, can move other entities. In the photographs and films that make up the exhibition, we can find rural workers, grocers, truck drivers, porters, circus performers, street vendors, human billboards, wagoners, and many others. They present themselves to the public gaze as mirrors as well as flashbacks of fragments of human survival, with the implications and subtleties of everyday processes. The exhibition also shows children, young people, adults, and the elderly who were—or perhaps still are—daughters and sons, mothers and fathers, grandmothers and grandfathers, loved or disliked by others.
What we don’t see in the images are the ones behind the lenses, showing us with their records how they saw everything they found along the way. The photographs and films that make up Moventes evoke the countless Sisyphi and Phoenixes that create and recreate movements, displacements, and gestures that demand endless efforts on physical, emotional, and spiritual levels, giving rise to life-death-life cycles. By living, humans build meaning and value for the cycles of life from the apparent banality of existence, consuming, in pain and pleasure, the potency of their own bodies, one day at a time. We must not forget that everything we perceive in the images can reveal to us our ideologies and worldviews. In this sense, the exhibition’s interest lies in sharing some of the ways photography shapes everyday displacements, often unnoticed and therefore invisible—waiting for someone to catch a glimpse and bring them into existence as narrative potency. Precisely like the many photographers whose works are part of the MIS collection have achieved with precision and poetry—whether it’s those who have been here before us, the many who are with us, or the ones who are yet to arrive after we are gone. Like all of them, we perpetuate the movement of shaping and predicting the future. With actions and worldviews. Valquíria Prates Curator
Clear Gestures to Confront
Pedro Ribeiro, Denise Abrantes, Rogério Correa da Silva, and Eduardo Pagotto moving through Eldorado (SP), Tabocas (SP), Vale do Ribeira (SP).
The field, the body, the tin can, and the basket hold the potent labor of the gestures.
The sun that pierces through clothes and skin sustains life flows and witnesses the twirls and twists—of earth and on Earth.
The hoe choreographs the treads that know how to open streams and nests
for the seeds that are thrown in the adventure of the fruits.
It is the nature of the peasants’ movement to sow and harvest the food
that touches so many hands until it is added to the matter of the bodies
that will invariably return to the earth.
Holding the repetition of the cycles and the weight of the materialities, they gesture:
until when must one cause (e)motion?
Untitled (1990) by Pedro RibeiroMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Workers at the Junuca Farm (1975) by Rogério Correa da SilvaMuseu da Imagem e do Som
The Names of Things Are Helena Tassara, Pedro Ribeiro, Denise Abrantes, Rogério Correa da Silva, Marcio Mazza, and Samuel Moreira meeting people in Tabocas (SP) and São Paulo. What do
children know?
What do adults fear?
Situations, worldviews, ideas, and ideologies.
Children know how to wait. They believe.
They interpret what is lived.
Adults can measure displacements in units of
time and space.
What moves the freedoms of those who are free
and their displacements?
What does a photograph inside another celebrate?
Once upon a time, Brazil (1993) by Helena TassaraMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Untitled (1990) by Pedro RibeiroMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Central Market series (1977) by Márcio MazzaMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Untitled (1990) by Pedro RibeiroMuseu da Imagem e do Som
E pur si muove
Pedro Ribeiro, Plácido de Campos Jr., Marcio Mazza, Samuel Moreira, Carlos Eduardo Mistrorigo de Almeida, Fernando Scavone, and Jorge Furtado displacing stories in São Paulo, Vale do Ribeira (SP), and Porto Alegre (RS).
To carry.
To drag.
To stack up.
To organize.
To choose.
From basket to sack to box to truck to cart in bags.
To cupboards. Refrigerators. Pantries.
From there to here.
From here to there.
Again. New again. Once again. The same other.
Repeats.
“e pur si muove” everything
that moves as it moves.
Central Market series (1977) by Márcio MazzaMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Central Market series (1977) by Samuel MoreiraMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Central Market series (1977) by Márcio MazzaMuseu da Imagem e do Som
The Phantom of Liberty
Roman Bernard Stulbach, Pedro Ribeiro, Rino Marconi, Fernando Scavone, Gabriel Bonduki, and the anonymous people who have crossed lives, streets, circuses, and street markets in São Paulo, Iguape (SP), Vitória (ES), Chapada Diamantina (BA).
The peasant, the grocer, the artist, and the street vendor
meet the housewife, the photographer, and the porter
in fruit rind,
under the circus tent and the market stall,
on the street,
on the roads that carry
those who arrive and those who leave
in the lives that touch on the skin of an image
in the art-life field.
slip away
in the certainties of the dictionary,
where “free is the condition of those who have freedom.”
Untitled (1990) by Pedro RibeiroMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Untitled (1990) by Pedro RibeiroMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Orlando Orfei Circus (1972) by Autoria desconhecidaMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Herta Orfei presenting a group of horses (1940) by Autoria desconhecidaMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Pery François, the clown (1920) by Autoria desconhecidaMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Weekly street market (1972) by Rino MarconiMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Untitled (1973) by Gabriel BondukiMuseu da Imagem e do Som
Governor of the State of São Paulo
João Doria
Vice Governor of the State of São Paulo
Rodrigo Garcia
Head of São Paulo State Secretary of Culture and Creative Economy
Sérgio Sá Leitão
Executive Secretary of Culture and Creative Economy
Cláudia Pedrozo
Head of the Cabinet of Culture and Creative Economy
Frederico Mascarenhas
PAÇO DAS ARTES ORGANIZAÇÃO SOCIAL DE CULTURA
Administration Board
Chairman
James Murray Sinclair
Vice Chairman
Marcello Hallake
Board Members
Mauro Andre Mendes Finatti, Renata Letícia, Roberto Giannetti da Fonseca, Rosa Amélia de Oliveira Penna Marques Moreira
Advisory Board
Board Members
Cecília Ribeiro, Max Perlingeiro, Nilton Guedes
MUSEU DA IMAGEM E DO SOM
General Director
Marcos Mendonça
Management and Finance Director
Marcos Campagnone
Cultural Director
Cleber Papa
Programming Coordinator
Renan Daniel
MOVING BEINGS
MIS COLLECTION
Curator
Valquíria Prates
Curator Assistants
Cristiane de Almeida, Patricia Lira
Image Processing
Guilherme Savioli
Research
Renata Tsuchiya