Capitol Marker from Hayes Notebook (1927) by Elizabeth HayesThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
How do you reconstruct a building if you don’t have images of what it looked like? That was the challenge facing Colonial Williamsburg's restoration architects in the 1920s and 1930s as they sought to restore and reconstruct the city of Williamsburg to its 18th-century appearance.
Two of early Williamsburg’s most significant buildings, the Governor’s Palace and the Capitol, had been lost to fire. Limited evidence depicting their colonial appearance had been found. A stone marker commemorated the otherwise barren site of the Capitol.
Capitol Archaeological Excavations (1920/1930) by Thomas LaytonThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
The discovery
In 1929, while archaeologists excavated the foundations of the Capitol building, Colonial Williamsburg researcher Mary Goodwin dug through archives in England for any information she could find about 18th-century Williamsburg’s buildings. Just before Christmas, she struck gold. Or, more accurately, copper.
Reenactment of Discovery of the Bodleian Plate (1950) by Thomas WilliamsThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
At Oxford’s Bodleian Library, Goodwin requested to view an engraved plate labeled in a reference book as an illustration of buildings “probably in some town in Virginia or Carolina.” It turned out to depict three colonial-era sites in Williamsburg.
Years later, a film about Colonial Williamsburg's restoration featured a re-enactment of the scene.
Bodleian Plate and Engraving Tools (ca. 1740)The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Engraved metal plates were used to mass produce art and images in the 18th century. A design would be engraved into the metal, then filled with ink, and finally pressed into paper. The Bodleian plate, as it became known, is shown here along with tools of the engraving trade.
Illustration of Williamsburg buildings, flora and fauna (not titled) (ca. 1740) by William Byrd IIThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
The plate illustrates several Williamsburg buildings as well as flora and fauna native to Virginia. Engraved sometime between 1731 and 1747, it provided invaluable information about...
...Williamsburg’s Capitol Building...
...the Governor’s Palace...
...and the College of William & Mary.
The Wren Building
Goodwin’s discovery of the plate was well-timed. Restoration of the Wren Building at the College of William & Mary was already under way. The plate provided new evidence about the shape of the building’s roof, which architects quickly incorporated into their design.
Wren Building (1935) by F.S. LincolnThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
The Wren Building is shown here in 1935, after the restoration.
John D. Rockefeller Jr. (ca. 1930s) by H.T. KoshibaThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
John D. Rockefeller Jr., who financed Williamsburg’s restoration, later said that without the plate to guide the restoration of the Wren, Governor’s Palace, and Capitol, “we would have been acting in the dark; with it, we have gone forward with absolute certainty and conviction."
The Capitol building
When reconstructing Williamsburg’s Capitol building in the early 1930s, restoration architects carefully consulted the Bodleian Plate, using it alongside historic records and the building’s recently excavated foundation, to guide their work.
Illustration of Williamsburg buildings, flora and fauna (not titled) (ca. 1740) by William Byrd IIThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
They did not include the chimneys shown on the plate, which sources revealed were later additions. To avoid a destructive fire, the original 1705 building did not have fireplaces. Realizing that government records were “exposed by the damps” they added fireplaces and chimneys in 1723.
Perspective Sketch of Proposed Governor's Palace (1928) by Andrew HepburnThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
The Governor’s Palace
Prior to the Bodleian Plate’s discovery, restoration architects had used available evidence, including excavated foundations, a floorplan drawn by Thomas Jefferson, and an 18th-century inventory of the building’s rooms and contents, to create a proposed sketch of the building, pictured here.
The plate revealed additional details about the building’s proportions, roof, cupola, balcony, and balustrade, which was all incorporated into the building’s reconstruction in the early 1930s.
Governor's Palace Gardens (2019) by Wayne ReynoldsThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
The plate also depicted part of the gardens at the Governor’s Palace, which landscape architects referenced when recreating the palace gardens.
The mystery of the Bodleian Plate
While the Bodleian Plate has provided valuable answers about what colonial Williamsburg’s buildings looked like, researchers have many unanswered questions about the plate’s origins.
The engraved copperplate was originally created to print book illustrations. But the image has not been found in any books published in the period.
Portrait of William Byrd II (1674-1744) (1700-1704) by Sir Godfrey Kneller (1646-1723)The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Historians have speculated that William Byrd II, a member of Virginia’s colonial gentry, commissioned this and other illustrations in the first half of the 18th century for a history of America that he never finished.
Byrd wanted to use his history to boost Virginia’s image, as people in England regarded the colony as a backwater. This might have been why he wanted to include illustrations of its elegant public buildings.
Engraver at Work (2023) by Brendan SostakThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Colonial Williamsburg’s engravers have created copies of the original plate, which enables continued study and use while protecting the original.
Illustration of Williamsburg buildings, flora and fauna (not titled) (ca. 1740) by William Byrd IIThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
In the 1930s, the Bodleian Library gifted the plate to the Restoration, recognizing its importance to the institution’s ongoing research. It continues to inform The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation’s ongoing efforts to accurately restore 18th-century Williamsburg.
Learn more about the Bodleian Plate, the Governor’s Palace, the Capitol building, prints, and more at colonialwilliamsburg.org.
This story was researched, written, reviewed, and edited by experts at The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation.
You are all set!
Your first Culture Weekly will arrive this week.