Aerial View of Gaol (2024) by Brian NewsonThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
One of the oldest buildings in Williamsburg, Virginia, the Public Gaol (18th-century spelling of “jail”) hosted pirates, spies, murderers, and runaway slaves. Imprisonment in the 1700s was full of misery, desperation, and illness. Now, it serves to educate the public.
A Map of the Most Inhabited Part of Virginia (The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation. Museum Purchase.) by Jefferson, Peter and Fry, JoshuaThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Construction
Establishing “law and order” was a top priority when Virginia’s government moved to Williamsburg in 1699. The jail was finished before any other government buildings, including the Capitol, and was financed through a law taxing the importation of liquor and enslaved people into Virginia.
Courthouse (2023) by Brian NewsonThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
County vs. public jail
Each county had its own jail, and county courts tried misdemeanors - petty theft, slander, debt, and other minor offenses. Alleged offenders remained in the jail until trial. The jail in Williamsburg was reserved for those thought to be the biggest threat to society.
General Court (2002) by Barbara T. LombardiThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
First steps to jail
For those accused of a felony, a local grand jury decided if there was enough evidence to stand trial, just like the American judicial system today. If the jury determined there was enough evidence, the accused was indicted (or formally charged).
"Cry Witch" (2019) by The Colonial Williamsburg FoundationThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Once indicted, the accused was held in the county jail before being transported to the jail in Williamsburg. Other than their jail cell, this was the last room the condemned would see before their execution.
Trials for the enslaved
Enslaved people were punished privately, but they could also stand trial for felonies and misdemeanors. The enslaved were tried at the county level after 1705, and their experience with the criminal justice system differed from that of white defendants. Justices of the Peace used shortcuts or eliminated steps in court proceedings. White Virginians went to great lengths to mimic their legal system, but justice for enslaved defendants was often elusive.
Abigail Briggs (2024) by Brendan SostakThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Status of those accused
After 1705, only free people of the colony stood trial at the High Court, including Abigail Briggs, a free Gingaskin woman accused of murdering an enslaved man in 1764. Briggs was convicted and later pardoned, but she was detained in jail for two years before word of her freedom arrived.
Public Hospital (2024) by Jerry McCoyThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Other inmates
Some inmates were not put in jail to await trial. Those who were mentally ill were housed in the jail until the opening of Williamsburg’s Public Hospital. The first purpose-built hospital for the treatment of the mentally ill in America, it began taking patients in 1773.
Public Gaol (2005) by Barbara T. LombardiThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Gaol and the American Revolution
During the Revolution, the jail held people considered dangerous, like spies, runaway slaves, and alleged felons. The increased population led to overcrowding and illness. A 1777 outbreak of “jail fever” (typhus) required thorough cleaning of the jail to stop the disease from spreading.
Public Gaol Pamphlet (undated)The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Layout and design
In the original design from 1701, the jail separated violent offenders from the “general population," and provided a single room as the jailer’s quarters.
In 1722, the government provided a two-story home for the jailor and his family. Additions to the building prior to the Revolution made space for Loyalists and spies. These cells were torn down after the Revolution and have not been reconstructed.
Public Gaol Great Room (2024) by Brian NewsonThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Jailor’s residence
The jail was staffed by the colony’s official jailor, which was almost a full-time job. One of the “perks” of the position was free housing, which shared a common wall with two of the cells. The jailor’s wife was expected to cook for her own family and the prisoners, and the children had to steer clear of the inmates.
Debtor Cell (2024) by Brian NewsonThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Debtor’s cell
Chronic debt was another offense that could result in jailtime. Debtor’s cells sometimes had fireplaces, making them better than the average cell. The debtor was put in the cell at night, spending the day working to pay off the debt.
Public Gaol (2021) by Brian NewsonThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
The jail cells pictured here date back to 1701 and are some of the oldest structures in Williamsburg. After two centuries of use, Colonial Williamsburg restored them to their original appearance. When infamous pirate Blackbeard’s crew stood trial in the capitol courtroom in 1718, some of the crew might have been kept in these.
Public Gaol Cells (2024) by Brian NewsonThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
The cell doors
Cell doors had to withhold escape attempts. In addition to metal reinforcements, the panels of the door were horizontal, making them harder to break down than typical vertical-paneled doors. Human error was responsible for attempted escapes, not the security of the cells.
Public Gaol Cell (2024) by Brian NewsonThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
The cell walls
The cells’ interiors were similar to the doors: wooden planks reinforced with metal brackets. Some cells had windows but, unlike the debtor’s cell, no fireplace or lanterns for fear of fire and subsequent escape. Prisoners were without heat or light for the duration of their incarceration.
The food slot
This slot opened into the jailor’s house, and food was passed through it. The jailor was responsible for the health and wellbeing of the prisoners. The government required that they be decently clothed and fed before trial. The jailor also summoned a doctor when a prisoner was ill.
Gaol Privy (2004) by David M. DoodyThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
The throne (toilet)
Fear of “jail fever” was a constant concern because overall sanitation was not a priority. The throne’s lid was removed, and gravity drew waste out of the cells and into a refuse pit outside the cells. The throne was also securely built to stop escapes.
Shackles (2006) by Tom GreenThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Shackles
Some accused had to travel great distances to Williamsburg for trial. The use of shackles was at the discretion of the sheriff transporting the prisoner. But that discretion could easily be abused and used to put vulnerable populations (like alleged runaway slaves) into chains.
Getting Branded (2003) by David M. DoodyThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Not all convicted felons were executed. Sometimes, the guilty could receive a commuted sentence. For example, by using “Benefit of Clergy,” which had origins in the Church but was available to all Virginians after 1732, a felon was burnt in the hand with a branding iron with a letter representing their crime. For example, "T" is for theft.
The Gaol and Gallows (1994) by David M. DoodyThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
Punishment
Those sentenced to death were briefly returned to the jail before their execution. A plain coffin was provided, and the condemned sat on it in the wagon on their way to the gallows. Once there, the felon stood on the cart with the noose around their neck and was “turned off the cart."
“Trap door” gallows were not common until the 1800s. Before then, the traditional Virginian gallows would have been a triangle on three thick posts. Execution by hanging was sometimes called “riding the three-legged horse.”
Tap to explore
Explore the gaol
Click into the image to explore the Public Gaol and jailer's residence.
Abigail Briggs (2024) by Brian NewsonThe Colonial Williamsburg Foundation
The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation gained possession of the jail in 1933 and opened it to the public in 1936 as part of the Foundation’s restoration of 18th-century Williamsburg. The thousands of people who visit this site each year learn about crime, punishment, and incarceration in 18th-century Virginia.
Learn more about Williamsburg's Public Gaol, Abigail Briggs’ story, and historic sites like the Capitol, the Williamsburg Courthouse, the Public Hospital, and the gallows at colonialwilliamsburg.org.
This story was researched, written, reviewed, and edited by experts at The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation.
You are all set!
Your first Culture Weekly will arrive this week.