Border-Crossing Actions Films

Transnationality Seen in Spaghetti Westerns, Martial Arts Films, and Kung-fu Films

Korean Film Archive

Yi Youngjae (Researcher, Sungkyunkwan University Center for Cross Culture Studies)

Newpaper Articles on Korean Oriental WesternKorean Film Archive

Today, the cultures of each country easily cross national borders. In particular, now OTT platforms have become major producers of cultural contents, the boundaries between continents, languages, and regions have almost disappeared. But even in the past, cultures have crossed national borders. Every time, of course, a corresponding 'variation' was applied. Let's take a look at what variation westerns went through when they arrived in Asia, especially Korea.

A Fistful of Dollars Newspaper Ad. (1964)Korean Film Archive

Arrival of Spaghetti Westerns

In 1966, a Western film was a surprise hit at the box office. A Fistful of Dollars was screened for 57 days in Seoul, attracting 290,000 spectators. This film, which was placed at the beginning of the boom of 'Spaghetti Westerns,' was introduced as the film directed by 'Bob Robertson', the assumed name of Sergio Leone for American market, and the fact that it was an Italian film was erased.

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly Newspaper Ad. (1965)Korean Film Archive

The spaghetti Western boom continued. On Nov. 12 of the same year, Django directed by Sergio Corbucci was released as a sequel to A Fistful of Dollars and attracted 170,000 viewers. Following this movie, The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, Blood for a Silver Dollar, The Return of Ringo, Minnesota Clay, and many other spaghetti Westerns were released in 1967. Words such as ‘wilderness, duel, and outlaw’ were added to Korean titles of these films.

Mounted Bandits Poster (1967) by Shin Sang-okKorean Film Archive

The Birth of Oriental Western

When it was revealed that these westerns were made in Italy, this led Korean directors to dream of the possibility of the Western outside the Hollywood. It was Shin Sang-ok who made this into a reality in Korea. In 1967, he released an 'Oriental Western,' Mounted Bandits. The wilderness, a lawless space, was smoothly replaced by ‘Manchuria.’ A 'wanderer' in the Manchuria rescues a British woman and independence fighters by attacking a Japanese military train.

Female Bandits Poster (1968) by Choi Gyeong-okKorean Film Archive

In Female Bandits (1968), the 2nd installment of the Mounted Bandits series made by Shin Sang-ok and Run Run Shaw of Hong Kong, Hong Kong actress Li Li-hua holds a pistol. The bandits led by her join forces with the Korean Independence Army to attack the Japanese army throughout northern Manchuria. The Oriental Western was a genre that could appeal ‘internationally’ at the time to the extent that it became a major material for Korea-Hong Kong co-production.

The area north of the present Tuman River, formerly called ‘Manchuria,’ is the frontier of China and was called ‘Manchukuo’ since 1933 when established by the Japanese army. This is a space that Korean films in the 1960s recalled as a place of struggle for independence. Manchuria, which was imagined as a land where the origins of a country sprouted in war films, has become well-known as a setting for Western films.

The Homeless Wanderer (1968) is an oriental Western version of Shane (George Stevens, 1953), which depicts a man leaving after protecting a woman and child. Directed by Shin Sang-ok, this film is full of stateless style. At that time, Manchuria was a multi-ethnic space, and Western fashion had deeply permeated here, so it could be said that it was a natural result that Manchuria became an exhibition hall for creative fashion and style.

In Break Up the Chain (Lee Man-hee, 1971), the true masterpiece and conclusion of the 'Korean Western,' 'the good', 'the bad' and 'the weird' help the independence army struggling in Manchuria against the Japanese army. This might be almost the only moment in which those who are more capable than the state and who exist outside the law played an active role in Korean films, which tended to be dominated by the big words of 'motherland' and 'nation.'

Companion of Westerns and Martial Arts Films

At a time when Korean theaters were flooded with spaghetti Westerns, another popular genre arrive at Korea. Yeong (Lim Won-sik, 1967) shows what could be called a creative compromise between Western and martial arts. Dok Go-sung, a ‘swordsman’ wearing a cape like Clint Eastwood in his spaghetti Westerns, saves the town and quietly turns away. At this time, spaghetti Western-style music flows along with the back of a lonely man.

Come Drink With Me Newspaper Ad. (1966)Korean Film Archive

The boom in martial arts films in Korea began with Come Drink with Me, directed by King Hu. In 1967, it was released under the Korean title of Duel of Wanderers and became a box office success. Soon after, three films by director Chang Cheh were released in succession: One-Armed Swordsman, Magnificent Trio, Golden Swallow. And these set an amazing records. As a result, two iconography were established in Korean cinema: 'sword' and 'one-armed man.'

The Showdown of Swords Begins

With the boom of martial arts films, Korean films incorporated ‘swords’ into their own film genre. ‘Swordplay’ or ‘swordcraft’ appeared after 1967 and peaked in '69. In Korean cinema before '67, especially in the tradition of costume dramas, swords were unfamiliar, because the Joseon Dynasty was idealized as a people-oriented country with virtuous government. The problem with swordplay movies was that they brought bloodshed and violence into this space.

Director Chung Chang-wha's A Swordsman in the Twilight (1967) and A Wandering Swordsman and 108 Bars of Gold (1968) were situated at the starting point of Korean swordplay films. These films are ones of the most beautifully executed swordplay films among Korean swordplay films. With these films, Chung, who created a unique style and rhythm for ‘Korean-made’ swordplay action, soon moved to Hong Kong and became the exclusive director of Shaw Brothers.

One-Armed Swordsman Korean Newspaper Ad. (1967)Korean Film Archive

Another trace left by the boom of martial arts films in Korea during this period is the symbol of a ‘one-armed man.’ Chang Cheh's One-Armed Swordsman was an object of enthusiasm that shined exclusively amidst the boom of martial arts films. Chang’s one-armed man played a role in incorporating a hero with physical defects into Korean action movies. Soon after, many Korean-styled one-armed men appeared in and out of the martial arts genre.

Great Swordsman Poster (1968) by Kang Beom-guKorean Film Archive

One-armed men appeared in many films, from Great Swordsman (Kang Beom-gu, 1968) to Snow Falls on the Bloody Street (Im Kwon-taek, 1970). In addition to these, a film even in the format of anti-communist films, A Special Investigator, One-Armed Kim Jong-won (Lee Won-se, 1975) incorporated this mutilated figure. One-armed men functioned as both a genre convention and a cinematic translation of historical scars.

Zatochi Poster (1962)Korean Film Archive

Another popular hero in the 1960s was Zatoichi, a blind swordsman. Japanese film, Zatoichi was the most popular series not only in Japan but also in the 'free world' throughout Asia. This series had a huge influence on martial arts in Hong Kong, represented by One-Armed Swordsman. The two heroes, a one-armed man and a blind man, dominated Asian film market at the time. That is why the meeting between the two was something close to ‘the inevitable.’

One-Armed Swordsman Film Still (1967) by Chang ChehKorean Film Archive

A movie was co-produced between Japan and Hong Kong in 1971. A one-armed swordman and Zatoichi face each other in this film. This film is titled Zatoichi and the One-Armed Swordsman in Hong Kong, and New Zatoichi Break! Chinese Sword in Japan. The duel between the two was an exciting spectacle, but as a Hong Kong-Japanese co-production, the winner in the Hong Kong version was one-armed swordman while the one in Japanese version was Zatoichi.

One-Armed Swordsman and Blind Swordsman Newspaper Ad. (1971)Korean Film Archive

In 1971, the Hong Kong version of Zatoichi and the One-Armed Swordsman was released in Korea under the title of One-Armed Swordsman and Blind Swordsman. Perhaps thanks to the popularity of Jimmy Wang Yu, who became the first Hong Kong movie ‘star’ in Korea with One-Armed Man, this film was a box-office hit, attracting 180,000 viewers in Seoul alone.

Seize the Precious Sword Poster (1972) by Im Kwon-taekKorean Film Archive

Seize the Precious Sword, directed by Im Kwon-taek, was an immediate response to this success. One-armed swordsman, blind swordsman, and the Korean hero Iljimae features in this film. This film is set in the middle of the Joseon Dynasty right after the failed Japanese invasion of Korea in 1592. The film follows Iljimae's journey in search of the king's treasured sword taken by Japan. On the way, Iljimae meets a one-armed swordsman and a blind swordsman.

Seize the Precious Sword Film Still (1972)Korean Film Archive

Seize the Precious Sword is a representative example of the successful adaptation of a global trend. By choosing the Japanese invasion of Korea in 1592, an international war that shook East Asia, as the background, the film introduces the heroes of the three kingdoms. But the blind swordsman in this film is not Zatoichi himself. It is a Korean 'adaptation.' A one-armed man is also 'adapted' rather than duplicated from One-Armed Swordsman.

A Precious Sword, a Knife of Thunder Poster (1969) by Im Kwon-taekKorean Film Archive

Some people raised concerns about the popularity and the overflow of these genres in the late 1960s. Their concerns were based on that the genre films were excessively violent and of unknown nationality. However, apart from the critical view, their popularity still remained the same. These films were a powerful resource for the male subculture that began to take shape in the '60s, and their statelessness was a strong sign of their internationality.

Twin Dragon Sword Poster (1968) by Gwon Yeong-sun·Son Ya-fuKorean Film Archive

Twin Dragon Sword, which is a film adaptation of "Jeonghyeopji", which is said to be Korea's first martial arts novel, shows how the Korean cinema appealed to the international market through martial arts. Amid the martial arts boom, Korea's Jeil Film Company joined hands with Hong Kong's Jade Alliance Film Company to produce this film based on the martial arts novel, "Jeonghyeopji."

The Painted Signboard of the Chinese Boxer (1970)Korean Film Archive

From Sword’s Point to Fist

Swordplay films, which originated from the popularity of martial arts films, disappeared after 1973 as the main genre of Hong Kong films changed. And the sword shifted to the fist. In 1971, when The Chinese Boxer, directed by and starring ‘one-armed man’ Jimmy Wang Yu, was released, Korean audiences immediately fell in love with boxing.

Fist of Fury Poster (1973)Korean Film Archive

Fist of Fury, which was released in Korea after Bruce Lee's death, attracted attention to be called an 'irrational exuberance.' As this film can be said to be an anti-Japanese text, the enemy in this film incurred the anger of Korean audiences. While the close relationship between Korea and Hong Kong has been established since the martial arts movie boom in the late 1960s, the Korean audiences have received this film as if almost half of it was a Korean one.

Enter the Dragon Poster (1973)Korean Film Archive

Starting with Fist of Fury in 1973, The Way of the Dragon, The Big Boss and Enter the Dragon were released the following year. The Bruce Lee boom, in Korea, strangely lead to the conclusion that a “true Taekwondo movie” is needed to correct the situation where “Hong Kong-produced shoddy Taekwondo movies are sweeping the world.”

International Police Poster (1976) by Go Yeong-namKorean Film Archive

Korean-Styled Kung-Fu Films, or Taekwondo Films

Set in Manchuria or elsewhere in Asia, men fight against karate masters or North Korean spies who wear clothes from an unrecognizable era or period. In these films, the enemy is usually Japanese, a communist. Even though these films assume an enemy who is extremely hostile to Korea in terms of history or contemporary geopolitical situation, their stateless background and fashion gave the films international characteristics.

Returned Single-Legged Man Poster (1974) by Lee Doo-yongKorean Film Archive

Lee Doo-yong hired Charlie Shell to make six Taekwondo films in 1974 alone. In the same year, the Motion Picture Promotion Corporation(current KOFIC) established a strategy to ‘encourage Taekwondo films’ in overseas markets. Another star was Bobby Kim from US. According to the press at the time, “a U.S. film company tried to present him as Bruce Lee’s successor. But he returned to Korea as he wished to star in Taekwondo films made in Korea.”

Bobby Kim (1975)Korean Film Archive

To match the popularity of Charlie Shell, Bobby Kim needed to differentiate himself. He too was good at kicking, but he chose to show off his ‘American masculinity’ by sporting his trademark mustache and leather jacket. This 'tough guy' took on the evil Japanese or communist. The enemies in the movies are highly Korea-specific, but the visuals and emotions contained in the movies were sufficiently international.

A Fistful of Dollars Film Still (1964) by Serio LeoneKorean Film Archive

From Spaghetti Westerns to martial arts films and Kung-fu films, these genre films, which were born as a response to international trends, were loved domestically as well as trying to gain international appeal. And at this point, the questions these films posed still seem valid; ‘What is transnationality in film?’; or ‘What is commonality across borders?’ In other words, these films question the ‘Asian commonality’ contained in these films.

Credits: Story

Planning and Production by Korean Film Archive
Curation by Yi Youngjae (Researcher, Sungkyunkwan University Center for Cross Culture Studies)
Production Arranged by Lee Ji-youn·Song Eun-ji
Edit Configuration by Agnes Park·Ko Sang-sok
Translation by Hwang Miyojo

Credits: All media
The story featured may in some cases have been created by an independent third party and may not always represent the views of the institutions, listed below, who have supplied the content.

Interested in Performance?

Get updates with your personalized Culture Weekly

You are all set!

Your first Culture Weekly will arrive this week.

Home
Discover
Play
Nearby
Favorites